802-522-2381
O'Meara Solar
  • Home
  • Grid-Tie Systems
    • Vermont
    • New Hampshire
  • Off-Grid
  • About
  • Contact
  • Blog
  • Portfolio

Solar PV vs Generator vs Generator w/ Inverter and Batteries

5/13/2014

1 Comment

 
Picture
I recently gave a Solar PV estimate for a customer who was building a remote camp, and unfortunately they decided to go with a generator as their power solution. I expect that at some point down the road they will go solar, as living with just a generator is inconvenient, noisy, and over time very costly. I know, because I lived it. When we first built our timberframe, passive solar, home, I went out and bought a very quiet and very efficient Honda Generator. This was to be our power solution for years to come, but after about a year of running the generator, and racking up 1200 hours on the new machine, I decided for many reasons that this was not a final solution for us. The next step in our power evolution was to add an inverter/charger, and a battery bank. This way the generator would run only for a short period of time everyday, servicing large loads, like laundry, and recharging the battery bank which would service smaller loads, like lights. This was a vast improvement over the stand alone generator solution, but it too was costly in gasoline, and was adding wear to the generator at too fast a pace. We finally had the capital to add a solar array, and we could not be happier. The generator now only runs in the darkest winter months, and our batteries are much healthier, as they reach float on a regular basis, which due to the longer slower charge rate was just not feasible with the generator.

 I feel like I lost a job due to the lack of understanding about what solar pv is capable of providing. The generator solution has a much lower initial cost, which is enticing, but it is a poor investment in the long run, less convenient, noisy, and less environmentally friendly. I thought I would put dollars to my own scenario to illustrate. As you can see at around year 6, solar pv pays for itself, and by year 10 the battery/inverter/charger solution starts to pull way from the stand alone generator solution. This analysis does not include any tax credits or incentives, assumes a 7000 hour life for the generator, and factors in the life cycle for the batteries.

Picture
1 Comment
Gabriel link
2/7/2021 05:06:46 am

Nice blog yoou have

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Author

    Solar Installers for Vermont and New Hampshire.

    Archives

    March 2017
    May 2015
    February 2015
    December 2014
    September 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014

    Categories

    All

    RSS Feed

802-522-2381
PO BOX 151, WEST TOPSHAM, VT 05086